Eyeless Jack x Reader- Now That You're Mine (2/2)

"I'm surprised EJ even made a move." Jeff said as he finished the last of Masky's cheesecake, most of the food exiting the side of his mouth that was cut from ear to ear.

Nothing much happened last night. You were at the hallway and Jack was about to kiss you again when the lights went back on. LJ and Jeff were headed back to the living room after Jeff and Jane messed the power circuit ( No idea what it's called ). They eventually saw you two so you both pulled away from each other, but of course, LJ and Jeff wouldn't leave you alone about it. You and Jack said 'Goodnight' to each other and separated ways. LJ followed Jack while Jeff followed you.

You didn't say anything last night but you did this morning. You figured LJ would have already known and you and Jeff were close so there was no harm in telling him. It's not like it will be a secret for too long anyway especially with LJ being a blabber mouth when it came to EJ.

"I really thought he liked Jane..." You said quietly. Jeff sneered, "Who would like someone like her? She always tries to ruin my beautiful face, how dare she?" he said while wiping his mouth.

Just then you both hear a shout, "Leave me alone, LJ!" Jack burst in the kitchen with LJ following behind him chanting "Do you? Do you? Do you?"

Jack, unaware of your's and Jeff's presence from the other side of the room plus his mask making his vision limited from the side views, he faced LJ then shouted "Yes, all right! I do! I love her! I love (y/n)! Are you happy now?"

You blushed deep red as Jeff shouted ecstatically, "Yes!" Jack looked at Jeff then saw you next to him, if you could see it, his face would have been redder than a tomato.

LJ and Jeff pushed you and Jack closer to each other. They high fived then left the room leaving you and Jack to your awkward silence.

Both of you were looking down and didn't know what to say. You were like that for a while until you broke the silence, "I love you too, Jack." you were smiling uncontrollably but couldn't look at him thinking you looked ridiculous with a beet red face and cheshire smile.

His head moved as if he looked at you through his mask. He immediately took off his mask then threw it on the counter, holding your face gently with both hands. He kissed you passionately and it made your knees feel weak. You kissed back, wrapping your arms around his neck whilst his on your waist lifting you up slightly. You both melted into the kiss, completely forgetting the world around you. It was as if nothing else mattered...

And that moment ended with a flash and familiar voices. You both pulled away then looked towards the door where LJ, Jeff, Masky, Hoodie and Jane were standing. LJ held a camera which was were the flash came from. Jeff and LJ cheered like complete fanboys, Masky's shoulders were slumped down until Hoody placed an arm around him making Masky smile from behind his mask, and Jane was leaning by the door with one hand on her hip then winked at you assumed both of you.

You were about to pull away from Jack's hold when he pulled you closer. You looked up at him, his mouth curled up to a smirk, "Where do you think you're going?" he said.

You blushed furiously, not knowing what to say. He chuckled at how cute you were then kissed you again.

The audience became uncomfortable now so Hoody led Masky away from the scene while Jane followed. LJ asked, "What now?" Jeff thought for a second then snapped his fingers, "Let's go ship Masky and Hoody!" LJ nodded in agreement, "Yeah!" then both left as well.

After they left, you two pulled away gasping for air.

"I love you, (y/n)."

"I love you, Jack."

He smiled sweetly putting his hand on your cheek then stroking it gently with his thumb, "I don't think I was able to ask this last night... And just in case." he cleared his throat, then asked, "Will you be mine?"

You grinned ear to ear, hugging him tightly, shouting "Yes!" He hugged you back gently, kissing your hair. "I should warn you I am a bit possessive..." he chuckled. "I know that already," you said pulling away.

He smiles then takes your hand, he was about to say something when your phone vibrated indicating a message. You took out your phone using your hand that was not intertwined with Jack's then read the message:

(Y/n), will you and Jack come to the living room? LJ and JEFF have something to show us.

                                                                                                        -Jane

"What is it?" your boyfriend asked, you answered, "Jane said we should go to the living room. LJ and Jeff have something to show us?"

"Then what are we waiting for?" he smiled, placing his mask back on, covering his handsome face. He pulled you to the living room where almost all your creepypasta friends where at. You and Jack sat beside Jane who saved the couch especially for you two. Ben, Smile and Sally were sitting on the ground just in front of you. Slenderman, Splendorman, and Trenderman were behind you with Toby just standing next to Slenderman. Masky and Hoody were sitting on the other couch. LJ and Jeff were in front of everyone, they looked like they had pictures and they were giggling like they were really fanboys.

"So that's where my camera went," you heard Slenderman say behind you.

Jack was holding your hand and caressing it gently with his thumb yet was looking forward. You giggled at how cute he acts when someone else is around.

Suddenly Offenderman entered then went between Slender and Splendor, directly behind you. Noticing you, he smirked then bended down a bit, his lips almost to you ear. Jack didn't notice, again, probably because of his mask. Offender looked down at your hand that was being held by Jack. Even without a complete face he managed to suddenly looked displeased, but that look immediately vanished when he spoke, "Why hello there, (y/n).", you and Jack looked at him though he was only paying attention to you, "It's been awhile," he said, his signature smirk never leaving his face.

"Oh. Hi, Offendy." you smiled, knowing he hated that nickname. "I told you to stop calling me that," "Well, I like that nickname so I'll keep calling you that." you stuck your tongue out making him move closer, your faces barely inches apart. "I oughta lick that tongue of yours," before he could do anything else, LJ and Jeff called for everyone's attention. Splendor pulled Offender back up, away from you. You looked at Jack who was now looking straight again but has stopped stroking your hand. You wondered if he was angry, but decided to give your attention to the twins in front of you.

They were smiling happily ( Not like they ever stopped smiling, especially Jeff. ) "We are here to embarrass everyone," Jeff stated as LJ chuckled. Everyone exchanged looks, LJ said "We have taken quite embarrassing pictures of almost everyone in this room," he pointed at you, "You too, (Y/n)." he continued, "But we will only show one embarrassing picture for one person while the other embarrassing pictures will be used for blackmails." Everyone started fussing and some were about to attack the two when Jeff spoke, "Now now, everyone calm down. You don't want anyone seeing something you don't want them to see." he chuckled making everyone fall quiet and just glare at them.

"Now that everyone's calmed down. Let's start!" Jeff shouted.

(This stanza contains the details of the different embarrassing pictures taken of everyone except you, Jack, and Jane. You can skip to the next stanza if you'd like.) LJ pulled the first picture which was of Ben, wearing Sally's dress. Ben blushed madly while Sally asked him why he was wearing her dress. Next was Trenderman wearing hipster clothes that were sooo no trendy, this made almost everyone in the room gasp in shock and Trender shouted, "NOOOO!" then ran out the room. Next, Masky's clothes were smothered in Hoody's face and he looked like he was enjoying it, "Hoody, what the hell are you doing with my clothes?" Masky asked while Hoody was blushing and speechless. Next, Masky had cheesecake all over his mask, obviously forgetting to take it off before eating. Next, Offender was holding Splendor against the wall with his tendrils. Offender shouted, "That did not happen!" he looked at Splendor, "Right, Splendor?!" his little brother was speechless and was looking away and slightly blushing, Offender growled at Jeff and LJ. "You can kill us later! We must finish this!" LJ shouted, showing the next picture. Slenderman was in the bath playing with a couple of rubber duckies and even had a shower cap on. Slender didn't react but just stood there,

Next picture was of you... You were wearing Eyeless Jack's mask and looked like you were playing around. You blushed then looked down, while Jack chuckled a bit. Next, from your bedroom door, the picture showed Jack sitting on the ground watching you sleep. You blushed deeper knowing that he watches you while you're sleeping and no one looks good in their sleeping state. Jack blushed as well, glaring at the two pastas in front. "Now for the last picture!!!" Jeff shouted glancing at Jane with a mischievous look as LJ showed the picture. ( Insert a very embarrassing picture of Jane I can't think of. )

Jane took out her knife then was the first one who charged at the two, mostly at Jeff while the others followed. Jack was also about to join the others when you held his arm making him look at you. You shook your head and his shoulders slumped and his body immediately went into a calm state. You smiled knowing such a simple gesture from you made a psychotic cannibal like him calm down within a millisecond.

You heard him sigh as he plopped back down the couch next to you, "Your boyfriend is not amused, (Y/n)." he said. You tilted your head to the side in confusion, he looked at you as he took off his mask, "Smexy was flirting with you, (Y/n)." you gave him an are-you-serious look.

"Jack, please. He flirts with almost everybody and I wasn't even entertaining him." you said. He furrowed his eyebrows a bit while staring at you. You were kind of scared, you remembered him saying he was possessive just a few minutes ago. This time you'll know just how possessive he is.

He stood up then carried you over his shoulder. You were surprised by his action then tried getting off him, "Jack, what are you doing?!" you shouted. He ignored your question as he started walking to his room. You kept struggling away but to no avail, when Jack got a little irritated since you wouldn't stop squirming, he slapped your butt and this made you blush madly and stop moving. "Don't you dare do that again," you said softly which made him chuckle.

You both arrived at his room and he threw you gently on his bed then hugged you tightly, "You're mine, all right?" he whispered in your ear. You smiled, "I'm yours... IF you'll be mine," he chuckled then brought his face close to yours, "Deal..."

He kissed you gently and you kissed back but it didn't last long before he pulled away then said, "I can do so many things to you, (Y/n)... Now that you're mine..."